Nursing Topics

Nursing Debate Topics: The Importance of Discussing and Debating Nursing Issues

This article was written in collaboration with Christine T. and ChatGPT, our little helper developed by OpenAI.

As healthcare continues to evolve, nursing debate topics have become increasingly important. Nurses have to make tough decisions every day, and discussing these topics can provide guidance and support. In this article, we will explore some of the nursing debate topics that are being discussed and debated by the nursing community.

Certification and Education

One of the ongoing debates in nursing is the benefits of obtaining certification in specialty areas such as wound care, oncology, or palliative care. Nurses who obtain certification in these areas are better equipped to provide better patient care. Another debate is about requiring nurses to obtain a master’s degree in nursing before practicing as a nurse practitioner. Advocates argue that a master’s degree better prepare nurses for the complexities of the role. Additionally, requiring certification in basic life support (BLS) and advanced cardiac life support (ACLS) can help improve patient outcomes.

Debate Topics on Certification and Education in Nursing:

• Are certification exams a reliable measure of nurses’ competency in specialty areas?
• Should continuing education be mandatory for all nurses to maintain licensure?
• Should certification be required for nurses who administer chemotherapy?
• Is it necessary for nurses to obtain certification in wound care?
• Should nurses be required to obtain certification in critical care before working in an ICU?
• Should nurses be required to obtain certification in geriatric care before working in a nursing home?
• Is certification in oncology nursing necessary to provide quality care to cancer patients?
• Should certification in palliative care be required for hospice and end-of-life care nurses?
• Should nurses be required to obtain certification in pediatric care before working in a pediatric unit?
• Should certification in pain management be required for nurses who administer pain medication?
• Should nurses be required to obtain certification in mental health before working in a psychiatric unit?
• Should certification in infection control be mandatory for all nurses?
• Is certification in IV therapy necessary for all nurses?
• Should certification in neonatal care be required for nurses who work in a neonatal ICU?
• Should certification in cardiac care be required for nurses who work in a cardiac ICU?
• Should nurses be required to obtain certification in public health nursing?
• Government responsibility in balancing public and private healthcare
• Is certification in occupational health nursing necessary?
• Should certification in forensic nursing be required for nurses who work in a correctional facility?
• Should certification in emergency nursing be required for nurses who work in an emergency department?
• Should certification in hospice and palliative care nursing be required for nurses who work in a hospice facility?
• Should nurses be required to obtain certification in informatics before working in an electronic health record (EHR) system?
• Should certification in nursing administration be required for nurse managers?
• Should certification in nursing education be required for nurse educators?
• Should nurses be required to obtain certification in case of management before working in a case management role?
• Should certification in rehabilitation nursing be required for nurses who work in a rehabilitation center?
• Should certification in diabetes nursing be required for nurses who work with diabetic patients?
• Should certification in home health nursing be required for nurses who provide home health care?
• Should certification in community health nursing be required for nurses who work in community health settings?
• Should certification in nursing informatics be required for nurses who work in telehealth?
• Should certification in wound, ostomy, and continence nursing be required for nurses who work with patients with chronic wounds?
• Should certification in gastroenterology nursing be required for nurses who work in a gastroenterology unit?
• Should certification in orthopedic nursing be required for nurses who work in an orthopedic unit?
• Should certification in perianesthesia nursing be required for nurses who work in a post-anesthesia care unit?
• Should certification in transplant nursing be required for nurses who work with transplant patients?
• Should certification in urologic nursing be required for nurses who work in a urology unit?
• Should certification in dermatology nursing be required for nurses who work with patients with skin conditions?
• Healthcare management: career paths and requirements
• Should certification in oncology nursing be required for nurses who work with patients receiving chemotherapy?
• Should certification in rehabilitation nursing be required for nurses who work in a rehabilitation center?
• Should certification in rheumatology nursing be required for nurses who work with patients with rheumatic conditions?
• Should certification in infectious disease nursing be required for nurses who work with patients with infectious diseases?
• Should certification in plastic surgery nursing be required for nurses who work with plastic surgery patients?

Scope of Practice

Nursing scope of practice is another area of debate. One of the debates is whether to allow nurses to perform certain surgical procedures without physician supervision. Advocates argue that this would improve patient access to care and reduce costs. Another debate is whether to allow nurses to prescribe and administer medical cannabis. Advocates argue that this would provide patients with alternative treatments for chronic pain, anxiety, and other conditions. Additionally, allowing nurses to assist with physician-assisted suicide is a controversial debate.

Exploring the Boundaries: Controversial Issues in Nursing Scope of Practice

• Is it appropriate for nurses to delegate certain tasks to unlicensed assistive personnel?
• Should advanced practice registered nurses be allowed to practice independently without physician oversight?
• Is it within a nurse’s scope of practice to prescribe medication?
• Should registered nurses be allowed to perform certain medical procedures, such as intubation?
• Is it appropriate for nurses to provide mental health counseling to patients?
• Should nurses be allowed to initiate treatment plans without a physician’s order?
• The debate over nurse practitioners operating independent clinics
• The role of nurses in prescribing medications: Overstepping boundaries?
• Should nurses be trained in minor surgical procedures?
• The debate over nurses providing anesthesia without doctor supervision
• The pros and cons of expanding the scope of practice for nurse midwives
• Is it appropriate for nurses to diagnose certain medical conditions?
• Should registered nurses be allowed to perform certain surgical procedures, such as wound debridement?
• Is it appropriate for nurses to administer anesthesia?
• Should nurses be allowed to perform certain radiologic procedures, such as taking x-rays?
• Is it appropriate for nurses to provide palliative sedation to patients?
• Should nurses be allowed to perform certain diagnostic procedures, such as ultrasound?
• Is it appropriate for nurses to perform end-of-life care tasks, such as pronouncing death?
• Should nurses be allowed to prescribe medical marijuana for certain conditions?
• Is it appropriate for nurses to perform certain complementary and alternative medicine therapies, such as acupuncture?
• Should nurses be allowed to participate in assisted suicide procedures?
• Is it appropriate for nurses to perform certain reproductive health procedures, such as intrauterine device insertion?
• Should nurses be allowed to perform certain cosmetic procedures, such as Botox injections?
• Is it appropriate for nurses to perform certain infectious disease control procedures, such as isolation orders?
• Should nurses be allowed to perform certain genetic testing procedures?
• Is it appropriate for nurses to perform certain therapeutic procedures, such as physical therapy?
• Should nurses be allowed to perform certain invasive procedures, such as lumbar punctures?
• Is it appropriate for nurses to perform certain diagnostic imaging procedures, such as MRI scans?
• Should nurses be allowed to perform certain mental health assessments, such as suicide risk assessments?
• Is it appropriate for nurses to perform certain pediatric procedures, such as circumcision?
• Should nurses be allowed to perform certain procedures related to sexual health, such as Pap smears?
• Is it appropriate for nurses to perform certain emergency medical procedures, such as chest tube placement?
• Should nurses be allowed to perform certain medical procedures, such as colonoscopies?
• Is it appropriate for nurses to perform certain cardiac procedures, such as defibrillation?
• Should nurses be allowed to perform certain respiratory procedures, such as mechanical ventilation?
• Is it appropriate for nurses to perform certain procedures related to substance abuse treatment, such as medication-assisted treatment?
• Should nurses be allowed to perform certain ophthalmologic procedures, such as eye exams?
• Is it appropriate for nurses to perform certain procedures related to sleep medicine, such as sleep studies?
• Should nurses be allowed to perform certain gastroenterological procedures, such as endoscopy?
• Is it appropriate for nurses to perform certain procedures related to pain management, such as nerve blocks?
• Should nurses be allowed to perform certain procedures related to occupational health, such as hearing tests?
• Is it appropriate for nurses to perform certain procedures related to addiction treatment, such as suboxone administration?
• Should nurses be allowed to perform certain procedures related to neurology, such as lumbar punctures?
• Is it appropriate for nurses to perform certain procedures related to cardiology, such as echocardiograms?
• Should nurses be allowed to perform certain procedures related to dermatology, such as skin biopsies?

Ethical Considerations

Ethical considerations are vital in nursing debate topics. One of the debates is whether nurses should participate in medical assistance in dying (MAID). Advocates argue that nurses should be allowed to participate in MAID because it is part of their role in providing patient-centered care. Another debate is whether nurses should be allowed to refuse care to patients who exhibit violent or aggressive behavior. Advocates argue that nurses should be allowed to refuse care to protect themselves and other patients. Additionally, allowing nurses to administer medical cannabis raises ethical concerns.

Exploring Controversial Ethical Issues: Debating Topics and Perspectives

• Is it ethical to use animals for scientific experimentation?
• Should the use of performance-enhancing drugs in sports be allowed?
• Should parents be allowed to choose the genetic traits of their future children?
• Should medical professionals be allowed to refuse treatment based on personal beliefs?
• Is it ethical to use genetic engineering to create “designer babies”?
• Should assisted suicide be legalized for terminally ill patients?
• Should individuals be allowed to sell their organs for transplant?
• Should healthcare be considered a basic human right?
• Comparing faith practices in healthcare: Sikhism, Judaism, Bahaism, and Christianity
• Is it ethical to use social media data for psychological research?
• The ethical implications of nurses participating in assisted suicide
• Debate over nurses’ right to conscientiously object to certain medical procedures
• The ethical challenges of nursing care in correctional facilities
• Nurses’ role in advocating for patient rights vs. hospital policies
• The debate over mandatory vaccinations for nurses
• Should there be limits on how much information tech companies can collect about individuals?
• Should the death penalty be abolished?
• Is it ethical for companies to use sweatshop labor?
• Should individuals be allowed to choose their own gender identity?
• Should there be limits on the use of artificial intelligence in military operations?
• Is it ethical to use AI algorithms to make decisions that affect people’s lives?
• Should doctors be allowed to prescribe placebos without informing the patient?
• Should pharmaceutical companies be allowed to charge exorbitant prices for life-saving drugs?
• Is it ethical to use drones for targeted killings?
• Should individuals be allowed to use deadly force in self-defense?
• Should countries be allowed to use torture as a means of obtaining information from suspected terrorists?
• Should whistleblowers be protected from legal action for revealing confidential information?
• Is it ethical to use big data to predict and prevent crimes?
• Should countries be allowed to conduct surveillance on their citizens in the interest of national security?
• Should genetic testing be mandatory for certain diseases?
• Should individuals be allowed to own exotic animals as pets?
• Should individuals be allowed to sell their own data to companies?
• Should individuals have the right to refuse medical treatment on religious grounds?
• Should medical professionals be allowed to disclose confidential patient information in certain circumstances?
• Is it ethical to use data mining techniques to target advertising to specific demographics?
• Should parents be allowed to refuse medical treatment for their children on religious grounds?
• Should medical professionals be allowed to conduct research on their own patients?
• Should individuals be allowed to sue for emotional damages?
• Is it ethical to use autonomous weapons systems in warfare?
• Should companies be held liable for the actions of their autonomous robots?
• Should individuals be allowed to modify their own genes for non-medical reasons?
• Should individuals be allowed to opt out of vaccinations for personal or religious beliefs?
• Should there be limits on the use of gene editing technology for animals?
• Should individuals be allowed to opt out of certain medical procedures for personal or religious beliefs?
• Should medical professionals be allowed to refuse to provide care to patients who have made lifestyle choices they disagree with?
• Should individuals be allowed to refuse medical treatment for mental illness on religious grounds?

Patient Care

Patient care is a crucial aspect of nursing. One of the debates is maintaining minimum staffing ratios for registered nurses in nursing homes. Advocates argue that this would improve patient outcomes and reduce errors. Another debate is about providing care for patients with different cultural beliefs and practices. Advocates argue that nurses need to be aware of cultural differences to provide culturally sensitive care. Additionally, administering medications through non-traditional routes, such as intranasal or transdermal, is a topic of debate.

Exploring Controversies in Patient Care: Topics Up for Debate

• Is it ethical to deny medical treatment to undocumented immigrants?
• Should patients have the right to refuse life-saving medical treatment?
• Should healthcare providers be allowed to use restraints on patients who are a danger to themselves or others?
• Euthanasia: an analysis of utilitarian approach
• Should healthcare providers be allowed to administer involuntary psychiatric treatment to patients who are a danger to themselves or others?
• Should healthcare providers be required to provide care to patients with communicable diseases even if they have personal objections?
• Should patients have the right to assisted suicide or euthanasia?
• Should healthcare providers be allowed to refuse to provide care to patients based on personal or religious beliefs?
• Should healthcare providers be allowed to disclose a patient’s medical information without their consent in emergency situations?
• The debate over rationing care in resource-limited settings
• The ethical challenges of providing care to non-compliant patients
• The pros and cons of alternative medicine in nursing care
• Debate over the use of restraints in patient care
• The challenges of providing care to patients with controversial lifestyles
• Should healthcare providers be required to disclose medical errors to patients and their families?
• Should healthcare providers be allowed to engage in romantic or sexual relationships with their patients?
• Should healthcare providers be allowed to perform unnecessary medical procedures for financial gain?
• Should healthcare providers be allowed to withhold treatment from patients who are noncompliant with their medical advice?
• Combating health care-associated infections: a community-based approach
• Should healthcare providers be allowed to prescribe opioids for chronic pain management?
• Should healthcare providers be allowed to use placebos in medical treatment?
• Should healthcare providers be allowed to participate in medical research without informed consent from patients?
• Should healthcare providers be required to provide culturally competent care to patients from diverse backgrounds?
• Should patients have access to alternative and complementary medicine treatments?
• Should healthcare providers be allowed to deny care to patients who engage in risky behaviors, such as smoking or drinking alcohol?
• Should healthcare providers be required to provide interpreters for patients who do not speak the same language as their healthcare provider?
• Should healthcare providers be required to provide care to patients regardless of their ability to pay?
• Should patients be allowed to sue their healthcare providers for medical malpractice?
• Should healthcare providers be allowed to provide medical treatment to minors without parental consent?
• Should healthcare providers be allowed to use physical restraints on patients with dementia or other cognitive impairments?
• Should healthcare providers be allowed to participate in lethal injection executions?
• Should healthcare providers be allowed to prescribe medical marijuana to patients?
• Should healthcare providers be allowed to provide medical treatment to patients against their religious beliefs?
• Should healthcare providers be allowed to use genetic testing to diagnose medical conditions in patients without their consent?
• Should healthcare providers be allowed to use telemedicine to diagnose and treat patients remotely?
• Should healthcare providers be allowed to prescribe off-label medication use?
• Should healthcare providers be required to report suspected cases of child abuse or neglect?
• Should healthcare providers be allowed to refuse to provide care to patients who are overweight or obese?
• Should healthcare providers be allowed to use restraints on patients with developmental disabilities?
• Should healthcare providers be allowed to provide medical treatment to prisoners?
• Should healthcare providers be required to provide palliative care to patients with terminal illnesses?
• Should healthcare providers be allowed to refuse to provide care to patients with mental health conditions?
• Should healthcare providers be allowed to use mechanical ventilation on patients who are brain-dead?
• Should healthcare providers be required to report suspected cases of elder abuse or neglect?
• Should healthcare providers be allowed to prescribe medication for conditions that do not have FDA approval?
• Should healthcare providers be required to provide patients with complete and accurate medical information?
• Should healthcare providers be allowed to participate in clinical trials without informed consent from patients?

Nursing Workforce

The nursing workforce is another area of debate. One of the debates is preventing nurse burnout and fatigue resulting from working 12-hour shifts. Advocates argue that this would improve the working environment for nurses and provide better care for patients. Another debate is requiring nurses to undergo regular mental health evaluations. Advocates argue that this would help identify mental health issues early and provide appropriate treatment. Additionally, allowing nurses to refuse care to patients with a history of substance abuse or addiction is a topic of debate.

Debate Topics for Nursing Workforce

• What impact does the nursing shortage have on patient care?
• Is mandatory overtime ethical for nurses?
• Should there be a minimum staffing ratio for nurses in healthcare facilities?
• Should nurse practitioners be allowed to practice independently without physician oversight?
• Should nurse practitioners be allowed to prescribe controlled substances?
• Should foreign-trained nurses be allowed to work in the US without additional certification?
• Should nurses be allowed to unionize?
• Should nurses be required to have a BSN degree to practice?
• Should nurses be required to complete a residency program after graduation?
• Is it ethical to require nurses to work rotating shifts?
• Should nurses be allowed to refuse to care for certain patients based on personal beliefs?
• Should nurses be required to take on-call shifts?
• Should nurses be required to work holidays?
• Should nurses be allowed to work remotely?
• Should there be a minimum wage for nurses?
• Should nursing programs be required to teach cultural competency?
• Should nurses be allowed to self-schedule their shifts?
• Should nurses be required to work a certain number of hours per week?
• Should nurses be required to complete continuing education to maintain their license?
• Workplace violence in healthcare: causes, regulations, and prevention strategies
• Should there be a cap on the number of patients a nurse can care for at one time?
• Should nurses be allowed to refuse to work in certain specialties?
• Should nurses be allowed to refuse to perform certain tasks?
• The debate over mandatory nurse-to-patient ratios in hospitals
• The impact of unionization on the nursing profession
• The challenges and benefits of travel nursing
• Debate over the role of nurse managers vs. bedside nurses
• The future of nursing in the era of AI and automation
• Should nursing schools be required to teach about the social determinants of health?
• Should there be a standard nurse-to-patient ratio for home health care?
• Should nurses be required to complete a certain number of clinical hours before graduation?
• Should nurses be allowed to perform certain medical procedures without physician supervision?
• Should nurses be allowed to administer anesthesia?
• Should nursing programs be required to teach about environmental health?
• Should nurses be required to have a certain amount of experience before working in certain specialties?
• Combating workplace violence in nursing: the impact of policies, legislation, and organizational culture
• Should nurses be required to undergo periodic drug testing?
• Should nurses be allowed to work while pregnant?
• Should nursing programs be required to teach about disaster preparedness?
• Should nurses be allowed to refuse to work during a pandemic?
• Should nurses be allowed to refuse to work in unsafe conditions?
• Should nurses be required to wear body cameras to prevent workplace violence?
• Should nurses be allowed to refuse to work in facilities that do not have adequate PPE?
• Should nursing programs be required to teach about healthcare policy?
• Should nurses be allowed to refuse to administer experimental treatments?
• Should nurses be required to have a certain amount of experience before working as a charge nurse?
• Should nurses be allowed to refuse to work in facilities that do not provide mental health support?

Harnessing the Power of Debate in Nursing Education

The art of debate is not just for politicians or lawyers. For nursing students and professionals, engaging in structured, informed debates can offer a multitude of benefits. Debates foster critical thinking, enhance communication skills, and expose participants to diverse perspectives, all of which are crucial in the dynamic world of healthcare.

Why Debates Matter in Nursing Education

• • Critical Thinking

Debating allows nursing students to analyze complex issues, evaluate evidence, and construct well-informed arguments. This skill is vital when making split-second decisions in clinical settings.

• • Effective Communication

Through debates, students learn to articulate their points clearly and persuasively, a skill essential for patient education, interdisciplinary collaboration, and advocacy.

• • Ethical Reasoning

Many debates in nursing revolve around ethical dilemmas. Engaging in these discussions helps students navigate the gray areas of healthcare, ensuring they provide care that aligns with their professional and personal values.

• • Exposure to Diverse Perspectives

Debates bring to light varied viewpoints, helping students appreciate the diversity of thought in healthcare. This exposure prepares them to provide culturally competent care and collaborate effectively with a diverse team.

Tips for Effective Debating in Nursing:

• • Stay Informed

The foundation of a compelling argument is knowledge. Regularly review the latest research, guidelines, and best practices in nursing.

• • Practice Active Listening

Before rebutting an argument, ensure you understand it. Active listening promotes mutual respect and often leads to more productive discussions.

• • Be Open-minded

While it’s essential to defend your position, remain open to changing your perspective based on new information or insights. Flexibility in thinking is a valuable trait in healthcare, where evidence and best practices continuously evolve.

• • Structure Your Argument

A well-structured argument is more persuasive. Start with your main point, provide evidence or examples, and conclude with a summary or implication of your argument.

• • Stay Calm and Respectful

Debates can become heated, especially when discussing deeply personal or controversial topics. It’s crucial to maintain professionalism, respect opposing views, and avoid personal attacks.

Benefits of Integrating Debates into Nursing Curriculum

Incorporating debates into the nursing curriculum can provide students with a platform to apply theoretical knowledge in practical scenarios. Here are some advantages:

• • Enhanced Engagement

Debates are interactive and dynamic, leading to increased student participation and engagement.

• • Skill Development

Apart from critical thinking and communication, debates also foster skills like research, teamwork, and public speaking.

• • Preparation for Real-world Scenarios

The topics debated often mirror real-world challenges in healthcare. Engaging in these discussions prepares students for the complexities they’ll face in their careers.

• • Promotion of Lifelong Learning

Debates often spark curiosity, leading students to delve deeper into topics, read more, and become lifelong learners.

In conclusion, debates are more than just academic exercises. They’re powerful tools that hone essential skills, promote critical thinking, and prepare nursing students for the multifaceted world of healthcare. As the nursing field continues to evolve, fostering a culture of discussion and debate will ensure that nurses remain at the forefront of patient care, advocating for best practices and optimal patient outcomes.

📎 Related Articles

1. Key EBP Nursing Topics: Enhancing Patient Results through Evidence-Based Practice
2. Top Nursing Research Topics for Students and Professionals
3. Mental Health Nursing Research Topics: Inspiring Ideas for Students
4. Top Nursing Argumentative Essay Topics: Engage in Thought-Provoking Debates
5. Top Nursing Topics for Discussion: Engaging Conversations for Healthcare Professionals
6. Exploring Controversial Issues in Nursing: Key Topics and Examples
7. Pediatric Nursing Research Topics for Students: A Comprehensive Guide
8. Top Nursing Research Topics for Students and Professionals